7+ Understanding Nigerian Law on Divorce: Guide


7+ Understanding Nigerian Law on Divorce: Guide

Authorized dissolution of marriage in Nigeria is ruled by a twin system reflecting the nation’s numerous spiritual and customary practices. The Matrimonial Causes Act 1970, a federal legislation, gives the first framework for statutory divorces, making use of uniformly throughout the nation no matter ethnicity or faith. Nonetheless, customary and Islamic legal guidelines additionally play a big function, significantly in areas the place they’re dominant, providing various avenues for ending marital unions primarily based on totally different ideas and procedures.

Understanding the authorized framework surrounding marital separation is essential for safeguarding the rights of people concerned. It ensures equity in asset distribution, baby custody preparations, and spousal assist. Traditionally, the authorized provisions have advanced to handle societal adjustments and to mirror a larger emphasis on gender equality and the welfare of kids. This evolution continues to form the interpretation and software of related laws and customary practices, in search of to steadiness conventional values with modern authorized requirements.

This dialogue will delve into the grounds for statutory divorce below the Matrimonial Causes Act, contrasting them with procedures below customary and Islamic legislation. Moreover, it can study the processes concerned in acquiring a divorce, specializing in jurisdiction, required documentation, and potential challenges. Lastly, the authorized ramifications of divorce, significantly relating to property division, baby custody, and spousal upkeep, shall be explored.

1. Matrimonial Causes Act

The Matrimonial Causes Act 1970 stands as a cornerstone of Nigerian legislation on divorce, offering the first authorized framework for the dissolution of marriages solemnized below statutory legislation. Its provisions outline the grounds for divorce, the processes concerned, and the implications for events concerned.

  • Grounds for Divorce

    The Act stipulates that the only real floor for divorce is that the wedding has damaged down irretrievably. That is confirmed by numerous info, together with adultery, unreasonable conduct, desertion for at the very least one yr, separation for at the very least two years with consent, or separation for at the very least three years. This represents a shift from fault-based divorce programs, requiring proof of marital breakdown somewhat than merely assigning blame.

  • Jurisdiction and Process

    The Act confers jurisdiction to listen to divorce petitions on the Excessive Courts of every state in Nigeria and the Federal Capital Territory. A divorce continuing usually commences with the submitting of a petition by one partner. The respondent is then served, and the case proceeds by numerous phases, together with potential conciliation efforts, proof presentation, and finally, a courtroom judgment both dissolving the wedding or dismissing the petition.

  • Property Settlement

    The Act grants the courtroom broad discretion in figuring out the equitable distribution of marital belongings. Whereas there is no such thing as a strict formulation, the courtroom considers numerous components, together with the contributions of every partner, their monetary assets, and their future wants. This discretion permits the courtroom to tailor the property settlement to the particular circumstances of every case, aiming for a simply final result.

  • Baby Custody and Welfare

    In all divorce proceedings involving kids, the paramount consideration is the welfare of the kid. The courtroom determines custody, entry, and upkeep preparations primarily based on what’s deemed to be within the kid’s greatest curiosity. Components thought of embrace the kid’s needs (relying on their age and maturity), the mother and father’ skill to offer care and assist, and the necessity to keep stability within the kid’s life.

The Matrimonial Causes Act, whereas offering a complete authorized framework, operates alongside customary and Islamic legal guidelines, creating a fancy panorama for marital dissolution in Nigeria. Understanding the Act’s provisions is vital for navigating divorce proceedings and defending the rights of all events concerned.

2. Customary Legislation variances

Customary legislation presents important variations within the context of marital dissolution in Nigeria. Not like the uniform federal framework supplied by the Matrimonial Causes Act, customary legal guidelines are numerous, reflecting the practices and traditions of assorted ethnic teams. These variations affect the grounds for divorce, the procedures concerned, and the potential outcomes relating to property and baby custody.

  • Grounds for Divorce below Customary Legislation

    Customary legislation grounds for divorce usually differ considerably from these stipulated within the Matrimonial Causes Act. Whereas the Act focuses on the “irretrievable breakdown” of marriage, customary legal guidelines might allow divorce primarily based on causes akin to barrenness, witchcraft accusations, persistent quarrels, or the spouse’s failure to carry out home duties. The particular grounds range considerably between totally different ethnic teams, highlighting the decentralized nature of customary authorized programs.

  • Divorce Procedures in Customary Courts

    The procedures for acquiring a divorce below customary legislation are distinct from these in statutory courts. Customary courts, usually presided over by conventional rulers or neighborhood elders, play a vital function in resolving marital disputes. The method usually entails mediation and makes an attempt at reconciliation earlier than a proper divorce is granted. Conventional rituals and ceremonies may be concerned, reflecting the cultural significance of marriage and divorce in these communities.

  • Property Rights and Inheritance

    Customary legislation considerably influences the division of property following a divorce. In lots of customary programs, property acquired through the marriage is collectively owned, however the extent of every partner’s entitlement might depend upon their contributions and societal norms. Inheritance legal guidelines additionally play a vital function, with customary practices usually prioritizing male descendants in property distribution. These practices can result in disparities and challenges for ladies in search of equitable property settlements after divorce.

  • Baby Custody and Parental Duties

    Customary legislation governs baby custody and parental duties following divorce, usually emphasizing the significance of the prolonged household in elevating kids. Whereas the kid’s welfare is taken into account, customary practices might favor the daddy or his household, significantly in patrilineal societies. The mom’s entry to the kids could also be restricted, and her function of their upbringing could also be topic to the customs and traditions of the neighborhood.

The interaction between customary legislation and the Matrimonial Causes Act creates a fancy authorized panorama for divorce in Nigeria. Whereas the Act gives a uniform framework, the appliance of customary legal guidelines introduces variations that affect the rights and obligations of people concerned in marital dissolution. Understanding these variations is crucial for navigating the authorized system and guaranteeing honest and equitable outcomes in divorce proceedings.

3. Islamic Legislation Procedures

Islamic legislation, also called Sharia, considerably influences divorce proceedings inside Nigeria, significantly within the northern areas the place it’s broadly practiced and acknowledged, though its software is primarily inside the context of private legislation issues. Islamic legislation procedures for divorce, whereas not formally built-in into the federal Matrimonial Causes Act, function by Sharia courts and are acknowledged below the Nigerian Structure’s provisions for customary and non secular legal guidelines. A vital side of Islamic divorce procedures is the idea of Talaq (repudiation by the husband) and Khula (divorce initiated by the spouse). Talaq historically entails the husband announcing divorce, whereas Khula necessitates the spouse returning the dowry or another type of compensation to the husband in trade for her freedom from the wedding. As an example, a case involving a wedding performed and ruled by Islamic legislation in Kano State would comply with these procedures, diverging from the stipulations of the Matrimonial Causes Act relevant to civil marriages.

The significance of Islamic legislation procedures lies in its provision of a culturally and religiously related framework for people adhering to Islamic ideas. It addresses particular grounds for divorce, akin to Ila (vow of continence) and Zihar (evaluating the spouse to a prohibited relative), which aren’t lined below statutory legislation. These procedures additionally affect issues of kid custody, the place the emphasis is usually on the kid’s welfare inside the framework of Islamic teachings, and property division, the place Islamic ideas of inheritance and marital property rights information the allocation of belongings. For instance, in a case of Khula, the Sharia courtroom would decide the suitable compensation the spouse should present to the husband, contemplating the circumstances of the wedding and the spouse’s causes for in search of divorce. These courtroom rulings can then function the idea for selections relating to baby assist and custody preparations, guaranteeing that the kid’s wants are met based on Islamic values.

Understanding Islamic legislation procedures within the context of divorce is of sensible significance for authorized practitioners, policymakers, and people in search of to navigate the complexities of marital dissolution in Nigeria. Challenges come up in circumstances involving interfaith marriages or when events disagree on the relevant authorized framework. The concurrent software of statutory legislation and Islamic legislation necessitates cautious consideration of jurisdictional points and the potential for conflicts of legislation. Nonetheless, the popularity and software of Islamic legislation procedures contribute to a extra inclusive and culturally delicate authorized system, accommodating the various spiritual and cultural norms of the Nigerian inhabitants. This acknowledgment enhances the authorized framework for divorce by offering choices that align with the deeply held beliefs and traditions of many voters, whereas additionally presenting ongoing challenges in harmonization and guaranteeing equal safety below the legislation for all events concerned.

4. Grounds for divorce

The willpower of ample grounds for divorce kinds a elementary element of Nigerian legislation on divorce. The existence or absence of legally acknowledged grounds dictates whether or not a divorce petition may be efficiently pursued in courtroom. The Matrimonial Causes Act 1970 outlines the only real floor for statutory divorce: the irretrievable breakdown of the wedding. This floor, nevertheless, requires substantiation by particular info, which operate as proof supporting the declare. These info embrace adultery, unreasonable conduct, desertion, and separation for specified intervals, every serving as a possible trigger for the irreversible breakdown. With out ample proof of a number of of those info, a divorce petition below the Act is unlikely to succeed. For instance, if a partner alleges unreasonable conduct, detailed proof demonstrating constant and insupportable conduct is critical to persuade the courtroom of the wedding’s irretrievable breakdown.

Customary and Islamic legislation, whereas additionally acknowledged inside the Nigerian authorized system, present various grounds for divorce, usually various significantly from these stipulated within the Matrimonial Causes Act. Underneath customary legislation, grounds might embrace barrenness, persistent quarrels, or neglect of home duties, reflecting community-specific values and traditions. Islamic legislation, however, might acknowledge grounds akin to ila (vow of continence) or zihar (sure types of spousal insult). The sensible significance of understanding these numerous grounds lies in guaranteeing that people in search of divorce pursue the suitable authorized avenue primarily based on their marital circumstances and the relevant authorized system. As an example, a wedding contracted below Islamic legislation might discover extra appropriate grounds for divorce inside the Sharia courtroom system than below the Matrimonial Causes Act. This underscores the significance of authorized counsel educated in each statutory and customary/spiritual legal guidelines.

The interconnectedness of “grounds for divorce” and the broader framework of Nigerian legislation on divorce highlights the complexities inherent in a authorized system that accommodates each statutory and customary/spiritual practices. Challenges come up when figuring out which authorized system applies to a specific marriage, significantly in circumstances involving inter-religious or inter-ethnic unions. Furthermore, inconsistencies within the software and interpretation of grounds for divorce can result in unequal outcomes, elevating issues about equity and justice. Navigating this advanced authorized panorama requires a radical understanding of the particular grounds for divorce acknowledged below every system, in addition to the jurisdictional guidelines that govern their software, as a way to shield the rights and pursuits of all events concerned. The authorized evolution of those grounds continues to adapt to societal adjustments and evolving ethical requirements, continuously shaping the panorama of divorce legislation in Nigeria.

5. Property division guidelines

Property division guidelines are an integral factor of Nigerian legislation on divorce. They dictate how belongings amassed throughout a wedding are allotted between the divorcing events. This allocation instantly impacts the monetary well-being of each spouses post-divorce and, consequently, the general equity of the divorce settlement. The Matrimonial Causes Act 1970 grants the courtroom discretionary energy in figuring out property division, aiming for equitable distribution somewhat than strict equality. This discretion permits the courtroom to think about every partner’s contributions to the wedding, each monetary and non-financial, their particular person wants, and their future incomes capability. As an example, if one partner primarily managed the family and raised kids, thereby enabling the opposite partner to give attention to profession development, this contribution could also be thought of in figuring out a good property allocation. Conversely, proof of monetary misconduct or dissipation of marital belongings by one social gathering can negatively have an effect on their entitlement.

The sensible software of property division guidelines in Nigeria is usually advanced, reflecting the various cultural and socioeconomic contexts inside the nation. Customary and Islamic legislation, the place relevant, introduce extra layers of complexity. In some customary legislation programs, communal possession of property might restrict particular person claims by both partner. Underneath Islamic legislation, particular inheritance guidelines and marital property ideas, akin to mahr (dowry), can affect the distribution of belongings. Moreover, the enforcement of property division orders may be difficult resulting from points akin to asset concealment, valuation disputes, and the restricted capability of the courtroom system. A case may contain a dispute over the possession of a jointly-owned enterprise, requiring skilled valuation and detailed examination of monetary information to find out every partner’s share. The shortage of clear title documentation for land, significantly in rural areas, additional complicates property division proceedings.

In abstract, property division guidelines are a vital, but usually contentious, side of Nigerian legislation on divorce. They purpose to realize a good distribution of marital belongings, contemplating numerous components starting from particular person contributions to the wedding to the relevant authorized framework, be it statutory, customary, or Islamic. Nonetheless, the sensible software of those guidelines is usually fraught with challenges, together with advanced authorized interpretations, evidentiary difficulties, and enforcement hurdles. Addressing these challenges requires ongoing efforts to enhance authorized readability, improve judicial capability, and promote larger consciousness of property rights inside the context of divorce proceedings, guaranteeing extra equitable outcomes for all events concerned.

6. Baby custody provisions

Baby custody provisions represent a vital space inside Nigerian legislation on divorce, governing the care, management, and upbringing of kids born inside a wedding that’s present process dissolution. These provisions purpose to safeguard the welfare and greatest pursuits of the kid, guaranteeing their bodily, emotional, and academic wants are met throughout and after the divorce proceedings. The authorized framework addresses numerous features, together with custody varieties, parental rights, and the method for figuring out custody preparations.

  • Greatest Curiosity of the Baby Precept

    The paramount consideration in all baby custody selections below Nigerian legislation is the “greatest curiosity of the kid.” This precept guides the courtroom’s evaluation of which guardian is best suited to offer a steady, nurturing, and supportive setting. Components thought of embrace the kid’s needs (relying on their age and maturity), the mother and father’ monetary stability, their emotional capability, and any historical past of abuse or neglect. Actual-life examples contain circumstances the place one guardian’s constant employment and steady dwelling state of affairs outweigh the opposite guardian’s erratic work historical past and frequent relocation, main the courtroom to grant custody to the previous.

  • Varieties of Custody Orders

    Nigerian courts can problem numerous forms of custody orders, together with sole custody, joint custody, and divided custody. Sole custody grants one guardian the unique proper to make main selections relating to the kid’s upbringing, whereas the opposite guardian usually retains visitation rights. Joint custody entails shared decision-making duties, though bodily custody could also be primarily with one guardian. Divided custody, much less frequent, entails dividing the kids between the mother and father. A state of affairs may contain joint authorized custody, the place each mother and father collaborate on selections associated to schooling and healthcare, with the mom having main bodily custody as a result of kid’s youthful age and the mom’s larger availability.

  • Parental Entry and Visitation Rights

    Even when one guardian is granted sole custody, the opposite guardian usually retains the best to entry and visitation. The courtroom determines the frequency, period, and circumstances of visitation to make sure the kid maintains a relationship with each mother and father, until such contact is deemed dangerous to the kid’s well-being. Supervised visitation could also be ordered in circumstances involving allegations of abuse or substance abuse, requiring a 3rd social gathering to be current throughout visits. A typical instance entails the non-custodial guardian having visitation rights each different weekend and through sure holidays, fostering a continued parental relationship.

  • Custody Modification and Enforcement

    Baby custody orders aren’t immutable and may be modified if there’s a important change in circumstances affecting the kid’s welfare. A guardian in search of modification should show a fabric change, akin to a relocation of 1 guardian, a change within the kid’s wants, or proof of parental unfitness. Courts even have mechanisms to implement custody orders, together with contempt of courtroom proceedings towards a guardian who violates the phrases of the order. For instance, if the custodial guardian constantly denies the non-custodial guardian their visitation rights, the latter can petition the courtroom for enforcement, doubtlessly resulting in sanctions towards the previous.

These aspects of kid custody provisions inside Nigerian legislation on divorce spotlight the authorized system’s give attention to defending kids’s rights and guaranteeing their well-being throughout and after parental separation. Whereas the legislation gives a framework, the particular software of those provisions will depend on the distinctive circumstances of every case, requiring cautious consideration by the courts to realize simply and equitable outcomes that serve the perfect pursuits of the kid. The evolving nature of household constructions and societal norms continues to form the interpretation and enforcement of kid custody legal guidelines in Nigeria.

7. Upkeep obligations

Upkeep obligations, also called spousal or baby assist, signify a vital aspect of Nigerian legislation on divorce. These obligations purpose to mitigate the monetary hardship usually skilled by a partner or kids following the dissolution of a wedding, guaranteeing their primary wants are met and their way of life is maintained to an inexpensive diploma.

  • Spousal Upkeep (Alimony)

    Spousal upkeep, generally termed alimony, entails monetary assist supplied by one partner to the opposite following a divorce. The aim is to help a financially dependent partner in changing into self-sufficient, particularly in the event that they sacrificed profession alternatives through the marriage to take care of the household. Nigerian courts take into account components such because the size of the wedding, the incomes capability of every partner, and their contributions to the wedding when figuring out spousal upkeep. An actual-life instance can be a long-term marriage the place one partner stayed house to lift kids, enabling the opposite partner to construct a profitable profession. In such a case, the courtroom might order the higher-earning partner to pay alimony to the opposite partner for a specified interval.

  • Baby Upkeep

    Baby upkeep is a authorized obligation of each mother and father to financially assist their kids following a divorce. This assist covers important wants akin to meals, clothes, shelter, schooling, and healthcare. The quantity of kid upkeep is often decided primarily based on the mother and father’ earnings, the variety of kids, and their particular wants. As an example, a courtroom might order a guardian with a better earnings to contribute a bigger share in direction of the kid’s schooling charges or medical bills. The precept is to make sure that kids’s dwelling requirements don’t considerably decline as a result of divorce.

  • Components Influencing Upkeep Awards

    A number of components affect the courtroom’s choice relating to upkeep awards in Nigerian divorce circumstances. These embrace the monetary assets of every partner, their incomes capability, the usual of dwelling through the marriage, the age and well being of the events, and the contributions of every partner to the wedding. Proof of 1 partner’s misconduct, akin to adultery or monetary mismanagement, may be thought of. A case the place one partner intentionally dissipated marital belongings to keep away from sharing them within the divorce might end in a bigger upkeep award to the opposite partner as compensation.

  • Enforcement of Upkeep Orders

    Enforcement of upkeep orders is a big problem in Nigerian legislation on divorce. Regardless of courtroom orders, some people fail to adjust to their upkeep obligations, leaving the recipients in monetary misery. The authorized system gives mechanisms for imposing these orders, together with attachment of earnings, seizure of belongings, and even imprisonment for contempt of courtroom. Nonetheless, these mechanisms aren’t at all times efficient resulting from procedural delays, challenges in tracing belongings, and the restricted assets of enforcement businesses. A sensible instance entails a state of affairs the place a non-compliant guardian relocates to a different state to keep away from paying upkeep, requiring the custodial guardian to navigate inter-state authorized procedures to implement the order.

These aspects of upkeep obligations spotlight the significance of monetary assist provisions inside Nigerian legislation on divorce. Whereas the authorized framework goals to make sure equity and shield weak events, challenges in figuring out applicable awards and imposing compliance stay important. Addressing these challenges requires ongoing efforts to enhance authorized processes, improve judicial capability, and promote larger consciousness of upkeep rights and duties inside the context of marital dissolution.

Often Requested Questions Relating to Nigerian Legislation on Divorce

This part addresses frequent inquiries in regards to the authorized processes and implications of marital dissolution in Nigeria. The data supplied is meant for normal data and doesn’t represent authorized recommendation. Session with a professional authorized skilled is advisable for particular steering.

Query 1: What constitutes grounds for divorce below the Matrimonial Causes Act?

The Matrimonial Causes Act 1970 stipulates the only real floor for divorce is the irretrievable breakdown of the wedding. This have to be substantiated by demonstrating info akin to adultery, unreasonable conduct, desertion for at the very least one yr, separation for at the very least two years with consent, or separation for at the very least three years.

Query 2: How does customary legislation affect divorce proceedings in Nigeria?

Customary legislation introduces regional and ethnic variations to divorce proceedings. Grounds for divorce, procedures, property rights, and baby custody preparations can differ considerably primarily based on particular customary practices. Customary courts usually play a job in resolving marital disputes, significantly in areas the place customary legislation is prevalent.

Query 3: What function does Islamic legislation play in divorce inside Nigeria?

Islamic legislation, or Sharia, influences divorce proceedings, primarily within the northern areas. Islamic legislation procedures, akin to Talaq (repudiation by the husband) and Khula (divorce initiated by the spouse), are acknowledged inside the context of private legislation issues. Sharia courts deal with divorce circumstances primarily based on Islamic ideas.

Query 4: How is property divided in a divorce below Nigerian legislation?

Underneath the Matrimonial Causes Act, courts have discretion in figuring out equitable distribution of marital belongings. Components thought of embrace the contributions of every partner, monetary assets, and future wants. Customary and Islamic legislation may affect property division, relying on the relevant authorized system.

Query 5: What components are thought of when figuring out baby custody in a divorce?

The paramount consideration is the welfare and greatest curiosity of the kid. Courts take into account components such because the kid’s needs (relying on age and maturity), parental stability, emotional capability, and any historical past of abuse or neglect. The purpose is to make sure a steady and nurturing setting for the kid.

Query 6: What are the upkeep obligations in a divorce, and the way are they enforced?

Upkeep obligations embody spousal upkeep (alimony) and baby upkeep. These obligations purpose to offer monetary assist to a dependent partner and youngsters. Enforcement mechanisms embrace attachment of earnings, seizure of belongings, and potential contempt of courtroom proceedings, although efficient enforcement may be difficult.

Understanding the complexities of Nigerian legislation on divorce requires cautious consideration of statutory legislation, customary practices, and non secular influences. The authorized panorama is multifaceted, and outcomes depend upon the particular circumstances of every case.

This text has supplied an summary of divorce legislation in Nigeria. Additional sections will delve into particular features of authorized apply.

Navigating the Complexities

People considering or present process divorce proceedings inside the Nigerian authorized system should possess a transparent understanding of related procedures and authorized ideas. The next suggestions present essential insights into navigating this intricate course of successfully.

Tip 1: Safe Authorized Illustration Promptly. Partaking a professional authorized practitioner specializing in household legislation is paramount. Such professionals possess the experience to navigate statutory, customary, and Islamic legislation, guaranteeing illustration aligned with particular circumstances.

Tip 2: Doc All Marital Belongings Completely. Correct documentation of all belongings acquired through the marriage, together with monetary accounts, properties, and investments, is essential for equitable property division. Complete information reduce disputes and facilitate honest settlements.

Tip 3: Prioritize the Greatest Pursuits of Youngsters. In baby custody issues, demonstrating a dedication to the kid’s well-being is crucial. Concentrate on offering a steady, nurturing setting that helps the kid’s emotional and academic wants. Doc situations demonstrating parental involvement and optimistic relationships.

Tip 4: Perceive the Grounds for Divorce Underneath Relevant Legislation. Decide whether or not the Matrimonial Causes Act, customary legislation, or Islamic legislation governs the wedding and familiarize oneself with the particular grounds for divorce below that authorized system. Adhering to those authorized grounds is vital for a profitable petition.

Tip 5: Interact in Open Communication, The place Doable. Whereas divorce may be adversarial, trying open communication with the partner can facilitate amicable settlements relating to property division, baby custody, and upkeep. Mediation companies may be helpful on this regard.

Tip 6: Be Ready for Potential Delays. Divorce proceedings in Nigeria may be prolonged resulting from courtroom backlogs and complicated authorized procedures. Endurance and preparedness for potential delays are important for managing expectations and minimizing stress.

Tip 7: Keep Monetary Information Meticulously. Hold detailed information of earnings, bills, and monetary transactions, as these paperwork could also be required as proof throughout upkeep or property division proceedings. Accuracy and transparency are essential for demonstrating monetary circumstances.

By adhering to those suggestions, people can higher navigate the complexities of marital dissolution inside Nigeria, guaranteeing that their rights are protected and that honest outcomes are achieved.

The forthcoming conclusion will summarize the important thing features of Nigerian legislation on divorce mentioned on this article.

Conclusion

This text has explored the multi-faceted panorama of nigerian legislation on divorce, emphasizing the interaction between the Matrimonial Causes Act, customary legislation variations, and Islamic legislation procedures. The examination prolonged to the grounds for divorce acknowledged below totally different authorized programs, the complexities of property division guidelines, the paramount significance of kid custody provisions centered on the kid’s welfare, and the authorized framework governing upkeep obligations to mitigate monetary hardship. The dialogue aimed to offer a complete understanding of the authorized processes and issues concerned in marital dissolution inside Nigeria.

Given the various authorized and cultural context inside Nigeria, navigating divorce proceedings requires cautious consideration of relevant legal guidelines, meticulous documentation, and sometimes, certified authorized counsel. Continued authorized developments and societal shifts necessitate ongoing consciousness of rights and duties to make sure equitable outcomes and shield the pursuits of all events concerned. Additional analysis and specialised authorized recommendation are inspired for these in search of detailed steering tailor-made to their particular circumstances.